We live in a world where artificial intelligence writes poems, paints portraits, composes music, and even more. What once required human imagination now takes just a few clicks and a few typed prompts. It sounds magical, but here’s the important question: If machines are starting to think for us, are we thinking less?
More and more neuroscientists, educators, and psychologists are starting to worry that AI, while incredibly helpful, might also be slowly dulling our creativity.
What Does Creativity Actually Mean?
Before we get into AI’s impact, it’s important to understand what creativity really is—especially from a brain science point of view. Creativity isn’t just about writing a novel or painting the Mona Lisa. It’s the ability to connect ideas in new ways, solve problems with imagination, and come up with original thoughts. It involves multiple parts of the brain working together. The prefrontal cortex helps with planning and thinking ahead. The brain’s dopamine system gives us that satisfying feeling when we solve something creatively or come up with a clever idea. Just like muscles in your body, these brain systems get stronger the more you use them.
AI Makes Everything Easier!
AI has quickly become our shortcut machine. Need to write an essay? AI can do it. Want to design a logo? AI can do that too. Want a fake photo? AI will handle it instantly. These tools are powerful and undeniably useful—but they come with a cost. They reduce the need to struggle, and in many ways, creativity is born from struggle.
Researchers at the University of California, Santa Barbara have found that what they call “productive frustration”—the time we spend thinking hard, failing, adjusting, and trying again—actually builds creative thinking. This frustration, though uncomfortable, strengthens the brain’s creative circuits. When AI removes that part of the process, we may get faster results, but we lose the workout that would have made our brains more flexible, more original, and more innovative.
What Teachers Are Seeing in Real Life
In classrooms, this shift is already showing up. A 2024 study by the Brookings Institution found that over sixty percent of high school teachers noticed a drop in original thinking in student assignments after the rise of tools like ChatGPT. Instead of coming up with their own stories or solving problems with creativity, students are increasingly asking AI to do the thinking for them. While the final product might look polished, the mental exercise is skipped.
This matters because creativity isn’t just about school assignments. It’s tied to life skills like problem-solving, adaptability, and thinking through uncertainty. When students stop practicing creativity in one part of their lives, it tends to affect other areas too. The brain doesn’t keep those skills sharp if they’re not used regularly.
What Happens to the Brain When You Don’t Use It
There’s a concept in neuroscience called “synaptic pruning.” It basically means that your brain gets rid of connections it doesn’t use. It’s the brain’s way of saving energy and focusing only on what you need. If you constantly rely on AI to do the creative work for you, the areas of your brain responsible for imagination, problem-solving, and deep thinking can start to fade.
Over time, this might lead to shorter attention spans, fewer learning moments, and a lower ability to think in new, original ways. A 2023 brain imaging study from MIT even showed that people who frequently used AI to complete creative tasks had less activity in the default mode network—the part of the brain that sparks when you’re brainstorming or thinking deeply.
AI Isn’t Evil
It’s important to remember that AI itself isn’t the villain here. In fact, when used in the right way, AI can actually boost creativity. Musicians use AI to experiment with new beats. Writers use it to explore ideas and get past writer’s block. Architects use it to explore complex shapes and designs. When people are active in the process—changing, reacting, and building on what AI gives them—their brains are still doing creative work.
The real problem comes when people start letting AI do all the thinking. If you treat AI like a co-worker or assistant, you stay in control. But if you hand over everything and stop participating, your brain stops thinking. And when that happens regularly, creativity begins to decline.
Dopamine and the Problem with Instant Results
There’s another layer to this issue, and it has to do with dopamine—the chemical in your brain that gives you a sense of reward and satisfaction. Normally, you get a dopamine rush when you solve a tough problem, finish a creative project, or come up with a clever solution. It’s your brain’s way of saying, “good job!”
But when you get instant results from AI, your brain still gives you a small dopamine reward—even if you didn’t really do the work. Over time, your brain starts to crave those fast, easy dopamine hits instead of the deeper satisfaction that comes from actually creating something. This rewires your brain to prefer quick fixes over deep effort.
A Cultural Shift Toward Speed Over Depth
There’s also a bigger cultural shift happening. We’re living in the era of reels, short videos, fast content, and constant scrolling. Everything is about speed. AI fits right into this culture, and in some ways, it’s making it worse.
This kind of “shallow creativity” is everywhere—pretty images with no emotional depth, catchy but empty quotes, and viral posts made for likes, not thoughtfulness. Deep creativity, the kind that leaves a mark, takes time. It requires focus, effort, and self-reflection. If AI continues to reinforce the speed-first mindset, we may lose touch with the slower, more meaningful side of creativity that makes us human.
How to Keep Creativity
The good news is, we’re not stuck. We can keep our creativity alive even as AI becomes more powerful. The first step is awareness. Once you know how creativity works in the brain and how AI affects it, you can make smarter choices. For example, you can use AI to brainstorm but still do the writing yourself.
It also helps to practice creativity in non-digital ways. Writing in a notebook, painting, journaling, forces your brain to stretch. Even boredom has value. Neuroscientists have found that the brain’s creative network activates when we daydream—something that rarely happens when we’re constantly staring at screens.
Spending time offline, walking in nature, or having long conversations can also bring your brain back to its natural creativity. And in schools, students should be taught not just how to use AI, but how to think critically, reflect, and build ideas from scratch.
Double Click 
Leave a comment